Science Surf
But let your communication be Yea, yea; Nay, nay.
For whatsoever is more than these cometh of evil.
Search

Primary Menu

Skip to content
Philosophy

Mixed model: peer review and lottery

27.12.2018 admin

When googling the above text, I found the text source  but even more important an earlier blog entry as well as a twitter survey

Related posts: Open peer review – publish first, review later | Open peer review failed | We are not suggesting that peer review is infallible | Phantastic, the peer-review system is broken | Peer to peer publication |

Post navigation

Previous PostThe perils of prizes and self-congratulationNext PostCRISPR CAS Babies: Doubt on the Sanger sequences
Disclaimer

Tweets

Most clicked

  • Eine Grenze zu setzen dem unendlichen Irrtum
    Galilei: Was geschieht? Federzoni: Die Nadel schwimmt! Heiliger Aristoteles, sie haben ihn niemals überprüft! Sie lachen. Galilei: Eine Hauptursache der Armut in den Wissenschaften ist meist eingebildeter Reichtum. Es ist nicht ihr Ziel, der unendlichen...
  • Der chinesische Menschenversuch
    This content has restricted access, please type the password below and get access.
  • How it is going, how it started – asthma genome wide scans
    Here are the most recent GWAS data for asthma – not identical peaks but quite similar How it is going 2021 PMC5901974 big.stats.ox.ac.uk pheweb.sph.umich.edu r2.finngen.fi www.ebi.ac.uk How it started: 1996-1998 third linkage scan (my thesis)...
  • Nature Genetics corrupted by 23andme
    This content has restricted access, please type the password below and get access. Related posts: Drop the last 3 nature genetics volumes from the libraries | Timeline asthma / allergy genetics | Parascience in nature...
  • A passion for precision
    The title is borrowed from  the opening Lecture of Theodor Hänsch on July, 7th, 2006 at the The Euroscience Open Forum in Munich and the Nobel lecture on December 8, 2005 [video] – one of...
  • Zur Geschichte der Heilpraktiker
    Der im letzten Jahr verstorbene und nicht unumstrittene Münchner Toxikologie Daunderer schrieb auf seiner toxcenter Webseite über das Heilpraktikerwesen als ungeliebtes Hitlererbe: Kritiker halten die Existenz des Heilpraktikerberufs für einen Betriebsunfall der deutschen Geschichte. … Weil Deutschland...
  • Does a healthy worker effect explain the allergy protection” at Bavarian farms?
    Unfortunately most studies in the farming environment do not report the prevalence of parental history. Neither did they report the effect size of parental  genetic risk in the farming population. This is, however, a critical...
  • LIMIT TO 5! What about a maximum of 5 papers per year per scientist?
    Undoubtly, there is an avalanche of poor research – as the Chronicle wrote last June, “we must stop the avalanche of low-quality research” the amount of redundant, inconsequential, and outright poor research has swelled in...
  • Die Ethik von Facebook
    Das mangelnde Bewusstsein von Facebook in ethischen Fragen war das immer wiederkehrende Problem von Cambridge Analytics bis zum Filterstream. Und nun finanziert Facebook plötzlich ein Ethik-Institut? Niemand redet mehr über die Ethik von Facebook sondern darüber...
  • Nylenna-Simonsen-Chalmers Misconduct Diagram
    The Lancet (10 June 2006, p 1882) had one of the best descriptions of scientific misconduct that I have ever seen (yes, I am also admiring Geoffrey Rose). The authors argue that our current view...
  • Cognitive bias codex
    I am sure, I wrote or talked about it before, but cannot find it. So here again –  a link to the cognitive bias codex plot of Terry Heick from https://www.teachthought.com (that is itself based on...
  • Das Problem des deutschen Ethikrates
    Das Problem des Ethikrates? Der Rat nimmt Stellung zu allen möglichen und unmöglichen Themen, kann aber meist die Fakten in der kurzen Beratungszeit nicht einordnen. Oder aber wertet sie mit nicht nachvollziehbaren Kriterien. Das war...

RSS Special Collections

Climate & Crisis

Genome & Editing

Daten & Schutz

Scientific Integrity

Adelsberger papers

Schweitzer papers

Allergy [RSS]

Genetics [RSS]

Joke [RSS]

One World [RSS]

Philosophy [RSS]

Software [RSS]

Theology [RSS]

Video [RSS]

Vitamin D [RSS]

SEARCH

Mixed model: peer review and lottery
https://www.wjst.de/blog/sciencesurf/2018/12/mixed-model-peer-review-and-lottery/
(c) Science Surf, Matthias Wjst
published 27.12.2018, accessed 18.08.2022